I’ve been on a quest for a long time, I’m talking years, to find a pair of flats that would work for me. For many years I gave up trying to find flats and decided to just wear sneakers or boots. One of the main reasons for giving up on flats was due to them never quite fitting my very narrow feet. My heels and ankles are really skinny and narrow. It’s made finding flats that don’t slip or flap off almost impossible.
Eventually, I discovered Tieks. They seemed interesting so I gave them a try. Overall, they looked ok, came in a ton of colors, but I had and still have problems with them.
- Tieks don’t come in half sizes. These are the one pair of shoes I’ve found that I could actually benefit from a half size in. Usually I’m a solid 7 in everything, but their 7 is a bit tight, and an 8 is too loose around the middle of the shoe.
- Not washable. My feet sweat like crazy in Tieks. I’m assuming it’s because they are so tight and are made of leather.
- You need to break them in, at least I had to. Some people have had really great luck with Tieks and can wear them out of the box; not me. I’ve had to wear Tieks around my apartment in socks, and then usually stick some big fluffy socks in the toe sections when I’m not wearing them just to give them a little extra wiggle room when they are brand new.
- They hurt my heels. Yes, I could put bucket this in with item #3 but I felt this needed it’s own callout. I’ve had grooves in the back of my heels and blisters from Tieks.
While I do have 4 pairs of Tieks, I was still on a mission to see if there was anything better out there. I had seen a number of ads for Rothys and I kept wondering if they were too good to be true. Their price tag, like Tieks, is on the steeper side so I wasn’t sure if it was going to be worth taking the plunge, but their return policy seemed pretty liberal so that was in the back of my mind. Then a couple of months ago, my friend and coworker got a pair and they looked pretty nice. They seemed to work out well for her, and she had no complaints so I figured what do I have left to lose.
Well, I took the plunge and I bought a pair of “The Point” shoes in Orchid, a beautiful purple. My research on the site showed that the company, and customers, recommended going with the Point version if you have narrow feet. When I pulled mine out of the box, they were literally the most comfortable flats I ever put on my feet. From the first moment I tried them on I literally had no complaints. I leapt and danced through my apartment. Still skeptical though, because in the past flats have felt ok temporarily, but then after a full day wearing them I wish I hadn’t, I decided to bring them to the office. You can return Rothys as long as you haven’t worn them outside and they are still in new condition. I packed them up in my bag and slipped them on when I got to my desk. Here’s what went down.
- There was no heel slippage. My shoes stayed on my feet successfully.
- No noticeable pain, although one foot felt a little tight near the toe area on one side. The site suggests sizing up a half size in The Point but I was too nervous so I didn’t.
- My feet sweated a bit, but I felt the shoe was more breathable than Tieks.
I’m now on my third full day of wearing Rothys and I can officially say I’m a fan. Here’s why I recommend them:
- No heel pain. None! This is unheard of for me.
- No heel slippage. There’s a nice heel backing in the shoe that makes things stay in place.
- Super comfortable! After wearing them for extended periods of time I have no complaints and they do stretch a bit, in a good way.
- True to size for me, but if you have a wider foot, going up a half size is probably a better idea.
- Washable! Apparently you can throw these suckers into the washing machine!
- Removable insert – and you can buy different color ones if you’re into spicing it up a bit.
- They are actually comfortable.
When I bought my pair, since I was still skeptical, I looked for a coupon code to get some money off. A lot of people post links to get $20 off so I was able to find one pretty quickly. If you want $20 off your first order to make it a little less pricey, check out my link! As a disclaimer, we both get $20 🙂
Happy walking!
8 Comments
Hi Katie! I see you’ve seen the struggles of narrow heels first hand.
I’m a guy, but have also had this difficulty with slip-on shoes my whole life, because of my own narrow heels.
We developed a shoe liner product called Skinnys designed specifically to solve the type of heel-slippage that occurs for people with narrow heels.
https://wearskinnys.com/
If you’d be interested in trying them out, we’d be happy to send you a pair.
Thanks! These look really interesting and promising!
Neat! These look promising!
This review was really helpful since I also have narrow feet (especially the heel) and struggle to find shoes that fit! I’ve been looking at Tieks and Rothy’s but hesitating at the price. Many of the reviews address wide feet, which are only helpful in knowing which styles won’t work for me. I’m curious whether you have purchased either “The Flat” or “The Square” from Rothy’s and if so, what you think?
hi, do this offer any support and arch support whatsoever?
No real support, unfortunately.
Hi Katie, I totally agree with you on Rothy shoe Point. I also write about shoes. I have found that their new version, the Point II, does not run narrow anymore? Where you aware of this?
I’ve heard the new version doesn’t fit the same, and people have struggled with sizing. I haven’t tried them yet.